我们在投稿的时候只能看到杂志对作者的要求,一般不了解他们后面在干什么活,了解一下应该对我们有一些帮助。作为新任《Medical gas res》的副主编,我最近接受了几项委派审稿专家的任务,在完成这个任务的过程中,了解到的一点“内幕”,分享给年轻的科研工作者,以希望对大家更有效地向国外杂志投稿有一点帮助。声明一下,《Medical gas res》属于BMC公司的,其他出版商的运行模式是否也是这样,我不了解。其中不一致的地方,希望了解行情的老师补充完善。
When assessing the work, please consider the following points:
1. Is the question posed by the authors new and well defined? 2. Are the methods appropriate and well described, and are sufficient details provided to replicate the work? 3. Are the data sound and well controlled? 4. Does the manuscript adhere to the relevant standards for reporting and data deposition? 5. Are the discussion and conclusions well balanced and adequately supported by the data? 6. Do the title and abstract accurately convey what has been found? 7. Is the writing acceptable?